July 2010
By Sam Lissner and Peter Rose
Hybrids like the Toyota Prius have sold well in the tri-state area, but plug-in electric vehicles (EVs) are only beginning to hit local showrooms. In the coming months automakers will unveil a new generation of electric cars that are specifically designed to eliminate oil-dependence and tailpipe pollution. With Nissan, Chevrolet, BMW, Tesla, Ford and Mitsubishi preparing to release their EV models, consumers in the tri-state area will soon find themselves with competitively-priced options to go electric and good reason to do so. But despite the many benefits of purchasing an electric car, the City of New York needs to incentivize investment in charging infrastructure before electricity can be a practical alternative to gasoline.
PlaNYC 2030, Mayor Michael Bloomberg’s sustainability plan for New York City, reported that transportation accounts for 22 percent of the city’s greenhouse gas emissions. As part of his plan to reduce citywide GHG emissions by 30 percent, the Mayor has set a goal of reducing transportation-related emissions 50 percent by 2030. In addition to phasing in hybrid busses and taxis, Bloomberg has cited the significant role that non-polluting EVs can play to limit future emissions. A “well-to-wheels” emissions study commissioned by the Mayor’s Office found that conventional gas vehicles emit three times as much CO2 per mile than EVs that are powered by the NYC grid (40 of local electricity is generated by nuclear and hydroelectric power plants). Because of the New York State Renewable Portfolio Standard (RPS), a state initiative to increase local production of renewable energy, electric vehicles will be increasingly powered by clean sources of electricity.
Despite the benefits of electrified transportation, it will be impractical to own and drive an electric car in New York City until carmakers and city officials address the range problem. Gas stations offer quick fueling service and flexibility to drivers of traditional automobiles. By contrast, the range of an electric vehicle is limited to the energy that can be stored in its battery. Technologies are improving, but today’s most advanced battery packs only store enough energy to fuel about 100 miles of driving, and require 3 to 6 hours to fully charge. Although a 100 percent charged battery should be enough to fuel most people’s daily driving, the range problem makes long trips unfeasible, and could be a game changer for suburban commuters whose drive times depend on unpredictable traffic.
Most homes are already equipped with outlets that will work perfectly for plugging in overnight, but charging an EV would currently be impossible for the 55 percent of New Yorkers without guaranteed parking spots, and for millions of suburban drivers who would need to charge their EVs during the workday. To help consumers realize the benefits of switching to electric vehicles, local utilities and municipalities will need to deploy infrastructure that enables drivers to charge their cars on-the-go.
It is vital that local leaders incentivize investment in smart meters and electric charging infrastructure across the tri-state area, but especially in New York City parking garages. In Vancouver, for example, policymakers updated a building code that requires 20 percent of new parking be equipped with outlets or charge points, and that electrical rooms be large enough to handle hardware upgrades that would to provide charging at all of the spots. A similar program in New York City would ensure that new development is EV-friendly. The City could also provide financing to help landowners upgrade their existing parking spaces to charge EVs. Mayor Bloomberg’s study concluded that wiring a commercial parking spot for EV charging costs between $2000 and $3500, which could be offset by a range of financial incentives including loan guarantees, tax breaks and small grants for EV infrastructure upgrades.
Although outlets in parking lots would make operating an electric car more viable for short range driving, they would not allow EV owners to take long uninterrupted trips. New Yorkers en route to Long Island for a weekend or holiday would never be amenable to stopping for hours of battery charging. To accommodate trips that are longer than 100 miles, municipal leaders would have to adopt one of the technologies that has been developed to solve the range problem. Better Place, an electric vehicles service company in Palo Alto, has developed robotic battery-swap stations that remove depleted batteries and replace them with fully charged units. Coulomb Technologies and Aker Wade are among a host of companies that are developing “fast-charging” portals that can charge a depleted battery in about 15 minutes. Government entities in Houston, Orlando, Detroit and Massachusetts are among cities and states in the United States that have already partnered with utilities and companies that will rewire select parking garages and install public charging stations. But leaders in the New York metropolitan area have yet to commit substantial political and financial support that would encourage the deployment of smart meters and various range technologies.
Worldwide demand for EVs is already robust, and large-scale production of a range of plug-in electric vehicle models will commence this year. We New Yorkers pride ourselves as being ahead of the curve, but to maintain that edge our leaders must set a strong example by investing in infrastructure that makes the city EV-friendly.